Vacuum attenuation method | Color water method | Microbial Challenge |
1. Convenient and fast testing 2. Traceable 3. Repeatable 4. Non-destructive testing 5. Small human factors 6. High sensitivity 7. Quantitative testing 8. Easier to detect smaller leaks and tortuous leaks | 1. The results are visible 2. Widely used 3. High industry acceptance | 1. Low cost 2. High industry acceptance |
High instrument cost and high accuracy | 1. Destructive testing 2. Subjective factors, easy to misjudgment 3. Low sensitivity, difficult to judge micropores Untraceable | 1. Destructive testing 2. Long test time, no operability, no traceability |
The most effective, intuitive and efficient leak detection method. After the sample is tested, it will not be contaminated and can be used normally | In the actual test, it will be found that if it encounters 5um micropores, it is difficult for personnel to observe the infiltration of liquid and cause misjudgment. And after this sealing test, the sample cannot be used again. | The experiment process is long and cannot be used in the delivery inspection of sterile drugs. It is destructive and wasteful. |